Anything new in History?

Name:

I am Head of History at Freeston Business and Enterprise College in Normanton, West Yorkshire. This blog is aimed at GCSE pupils in the school as an opportunity for them to debate some of the big issues being studied in our Modern World History course.

Thursday, November 24, 2005

GCSE Coursework

GCSE Coursework

Vietnam

Course content



Vietnam since 1939

Key Issues Content Focus

Part 1: Origins of Conflict  

Why did the French leave Vietnam in 1954 and the United States become involved?
French war 1946-54; Dien BienPhu, 1954; Domino Theory; NgoDinh Diem, 1956-63; Gulf ofTonkin incident, 1964.

Part 2: Vietnam: the Military Experience
                    
How effective were the U.S. intheir attempts to defeat theguerrilla tactics used against them in the Vietnam War? Theory of Guerrilla Warfare;Guerrilla tactics, 1965-1973;
U.S.response: Rolling Thunder, 1965;Tet Offensive, 1968; AgentOrange & Napalm; US Bombingof the North, 1970-72.

Part 3: Vietnam: the Civilian Experience

How did the experience of war lead to the peace movement in America?
My Lai, 1968; TV and media coverage; Protest movement, 1968-73.

Part 4: Vietnam: Finding Peace

Why has peace been difficult to find for the people of Vietnam?
US withdrawal, 1973-75; Fall of Saigon, 1975;
Boat people and economic problems. Long term effects of chemical warfare.
















Question –    Explain why the USA withdrew it’s forces from
            Vietnam in  1973.

‘Explain’ means that you must give reasons why the USA took troops out of Vietnam.

Think
          Who made the decision to pull out the forces?
          Why were US forces there in the first place?
          Had they achieved their objective?
          Why was the year 1973 chosen?
          What factors could have influenced the decision makers?
          Which reasons were the most important?
          How are the reasons linked?

You are going to be asked to show your understanding of causation. Marks will be awarded for doing the following;


Level 1     A simple description of  some of the causes, telling the story.
                                        (1-5 marks)

Level 2     Shows simple understanding and uses some relevant information to try to answer the question.
     May concentrate on only one factor.
     May tell the story but not really link answer to the question.
     May identify several factors but not clearly linked to the question and little evidence to support answer.
                                   (6-12 marks)

Level 3     Uses relevant material, develops and makes links between several factors and explains how they are linked to the question.
                                        (13-20 marks)

Level 4
Complex understanding will be demonstrated by building on Level 3 but will show  understanding of how complex the past was and how the factors were intertwined. Will make judgements on the relationships between causes, may comment on long term and short term causes and may put forward a conclusion that suggests which factors were the most important.









ESSAY GUIDANCE

WHY DID THE USA LEAVE VIETNAM BY 1973?


Introduction
          What is the short answer to the question?


Paragraph 1
          Set the scene, explain why the USA became involved in Vietnam
  • Cold War – Containment-Domino Theory

  • Support for France

  • Partition of Vietnam, North is communist, South is non-communist.

  • USA supports South and Diem

Paragraph 2     
Explain why Diem was a bad choice, why he was unpopular in South Vietnam. US policy ‘backed the wrong horse’.
  • Strategic hamlets

  • Pro Catholic.

  • Angered farmers.

  • US policy of advisers and money continued by Eisenhower and Kennedy.

Paragraph 3
Explain how the USA escalated the conflict under Johnson and the tactics uesd. How the USA were going to fight a technological war and how these tactics proved to be ineffective.
  • Gulf of Tonkin episode

  • Increased use of ground troops (500,000 by 1968)

  • Bombing of North Vietnam and  Viet Cong

  • Lack of success, fighting a technological war against guerilla tactics.

Paragraph 4
          Why were the Viet Cong so good at guerilla tactics.
  • Experience

  • Supplies, Ho Chi Minh trail, Russia and China.

  • Tunnels

  • Support of peasants

  • US troops young and inexperienced.

Paragraph 5     
          US tactics become desperate and counterproductive
  • Chemical weapons

  • My Lai

  • Tet Offensive

  • Bombing campaign only strengthens the resolve of North Vietnam.

Paragraph 6
The war becomes unpopular, growth of protest movements.Negative impact on public opinion in the USA and the world.
  • Draft dodgers

  • Student protests

  • Veterans protest

  • Woodstock, Hippy era, Peace and Love.

  • Kent University.

Paragraph 7
          The role of the media in bringing home the horrors of the war.
  • 1964 approval rating  for war high.

  • TV war, photos

  • Deaths

  • Attrocities, eg My Lai

  • Tet Offensive – role of Walter Cronkite.

  • Anti-war protests.


Paragraph 8
          The response of the politicians.
  • Cost of war, cutbacks on Great Reform programme.

  • Johnson does not stand for re-election

  • Nixon vows to get USA out

  • Negotiates peace settlement, Vietnamisation

  • 1973 peace agreement signed

  • 1975 USA withdraws, South Vietnam falls to communism.

Conclusion
          US policy failed in Vietnam, 58,000 dead.
          What do you think are the main reasons for the US admitting defeat?
















Tuesday, November 15, 2005

YEAR 11 GCSE HISTORY

YEAR 11 GCSE HISTORY

What you have to do this year;

  • Complete topic on ‘The Cold War’ 1945-1949.

  • Look at the Vietnam War and begin coursework assignment.

  • Prepare your presentations on the Vietnam War.

  • Remember the trip to Beth Shalom on Monday 21 November. Look at the following website before the visit;
http://www.holocaustcentre.net/


  • Revise for trial exams in December; there are two Papers,

  • Paper 1 – There will be four questions, you must choose to answer 3 of them. They will cover the following topics;
* Causes of WW1
* The League of Nations
* Causes of World War 2
* The Cold War

  • Paper 2 – There will be two questions on the USA, 1919-1941.

  • There will be revision sessions in the weeks before the exam. Use the revision booklets given out in the lessons.

  • Use the websites,
www.schoolhistory.co.uk
www.johndclare.net
     use the links on the websites to reach other relevant websites.


Monday, November 14, 2005

Vietnam Coursework (Year 11)

GCSE Coursework

Vietnam

Course content



Vietnam since 1939

Key Issues Content Focus

Part 1: Origins of Conflict

Why did the French leave Vietnam in 1954 and the United States become involved?
French war 1946-54; Dien BienPhu, 1954; Domino Theory; NgoDinh Diem, 1956-63; Gulf ofTonkin incident, 1964.

Part 2: Vietnam: the Military Experience

How effective were the U.S. intheir attempts to defeat theguerrilla tactics used against them in the Vietnam War? Theory of Guerrilla Warfare;Guerrilla tactics, 1965-1973;
U.S.response: Rolling Thunder, 1965;Tet Offensive, 1968; AgentOrange & Napalm; US Bombingof the North, 1970-72.

Part 3: Vietnam: the Civilian Experience

How did the experience of war lead to the peace movement in America?
My Lai, 1968; TV and media coverage; Protest movement, 1968-73.

Part 4: Vietnam: Finding Peace

Why has peace been difficult to find for the people of Vietnam?
US withdrawal, 1973-75; Fall of Saigon, 1975;
Boat people and economic problems. Long term effects of chemical warfare














USEFUL WEBLINKS

Investigating the Vietnam War


In common with all Spartacus sites, this provided splendid information, clear navigation and excellent links. An unmissable resource perfect for use at GCSE with interviews and projects (questions to research with guidance).




Vietnam

An site providing geographical and cultural information about Vietnam, with a brief but beneficial section on the country's history.



LearnHistory.org.uk

Clear and easy to follow guide answering the key questions about the Vietnam war with sources and additional links for further explanation.



VietnamWar.net

An enormous site that presents information about all aspects of the Vietnam conflict. A portal to basically every Vietnam site on the internet - excellent for research.



Vietnam Interactive Portfolio

This site presents many photos taken during the Vietnam Conflict. Excellent source material taken by a serving American during the conflict.



Vietnam's most harrowing photo

Detailed analysis of the famous Vietnam photo depicting children fleeing an American Napalm attack. Excellent analysis spoilt by intrusive advertising.



Vietnam War

A site dedicated to telling the 'truth' about the war. Some useful resources and information relating to the Vietnam conflict, yet lots of text to wade through.



The Vietnam War

Programme notes from an American documentary - excellent comprehensive background and analysis into the conflict.



Battlefield Vietnam

From the same source as the above listing, this site concentrates on the actual fighting that took place. Useful material on tactics


http://www.spartacus.schoolnet.co.uk/vietnam.html

http://www.learnhistory.org.uk/vietnam/index.htm

http://www.bbc.co.uk/schools/gcsebitesize/history/usa/vietnamrev4.shtml